Bologna - Paris: Comparing Experiences

by Alberto Borghi

A week in Paris at the Institut National des Jeunes Aveugles: a group of teenagers living with vision loss from Cavazza experience the City of Light.


Crossing the now theoretical boundaries of the European Union to widen one's own perceptions of diverse realities, even for those who share a physical limitation that makes the reality of the surroundings more difficult to make sense of.
In short, this is the meaning of the experience reached by the 17 adolescents who participate in the telephone operators' program offered by the Istituto Cavazza. They travelled to Paris from September 23rd to October 1st and were guests at the Institut National des Jeunes Aveugles (INJA). Students from INJA had come to Cavazza in the spring before that.
We met Vania, Giuseppina, Ivan and Roberto to understand what they were most impressed with during their week-stay in Paris. There seemed to be a certain degree of wariness about the pedagogical approach used by the very well-known Paris institution, founded in 1784 by Valentin Hauy to guarantee an education to blind and visually impaired students. Braille's nation, in fact, in regards to its own conception of an approach strongly statist and centralist, expects INJA to have national competence regarding the education of blind and visually impaired students, directly by being host of 150 students, or indirectly, through specific counselling for students who try to integrate regular schools.
The choice between a regular school and a special school is entrusted to a team of specialized physicians and parents, who assess the specific aptitudes of each student.
What puzzled Vania and her friends is the strong discipline of the Paris institution. She thought about these moments of astonishment when their young French counterparts, during the few occasions in which they were able to spend time together in the evening (also because of the age difference), simply vanished at 10 o'clock, leaving their guests alone, because it was curfew time, apparently unchangeable only for five minutes. So, the students of the City of Light did seem rather formal; while in Bologna they had shown a more carefree and spontaneous attitude.
It must be remembered that at the Institut National des Jeunes Aveugles, kids can arrive there at the young age of 11 years old, often far away from their parents for extended periods of time. Nevertheless, blind students, once they receive their diploma, they can go to university staying in dorms with their colleagues, without any particular problems.

Picture - Students and instructors on an excursion

The "Bolognese" were astounded to hear that some transalpine people living with vision loss, once their studies are over, choose to receive a disability pension rather than integrate the workforce (by going through an operators' course, for example, it has to be said, however, that the number of necessary operators is established by the State every five years). But, it is also true that this underlines a certain attention by the State towards people with disabilities with specific funds dedicated to each student and amounting to about 60,000 € for assistance, and disability benefits obviously sufficient to take care of oneself.
Cavazza's students were able to realize, when visiting Paris, some gaps that blind people need to face, surprisingly, given the fact that this is the city in which lived Louis Braille. For example, on many underground lines, the platforms do not have the tactile protections necessary on the ramps. The cars have shutting systems for the doors that are too sudden. Also, nothing indicates from which side one needs to get off from. The buses do not have a voice synthesis system to inform passengers of the stops that are coming up. And, the acoustic signal of the street lights can simply abandon you right in the middle of an intersection often with

delays for crossing good enough for a hundred-metre sprinter. In regards to the attention for blind people by the citizens, Paris is not unfaithful to its own tradition of a rude and distracted metropolis, but according to Vania and her friends, this is probably due to the daily and widespread presence of blind people in the urban environment.
Despite the logistic difficulties (which can be overcome, after all), Paris has unveiled its beauty to the young group of people from Cavazza, also thanks to professor Salvo Falcone, teacher of Italian at INJA, expert in this type of international exchange, and thanks also to the companions of the Istituto Cavazza. The visit to the City of Science and Industry at La Villette was really appreciated. Guiding was provided by the person who was in charge of accessibility for blind people at the museum. A disappointing experience at the Louvre though because there were no services dedicated to blind visitors.
The intercultural exchange, after all, really was a success, so much so that those who participated have expressed the desire to travel elsewhere, maybe in London or Berlin, capitals in a Europe truly without boundaries.

Picture - City of Science and Industry at La Villette, Paris

Previous Article Back to the Table of Contents Next Article